I have an old high school boyfriend I’m still in touch with once a year or so: a few emails go back and forth with newsy updates, and then that’s it for another year or so. I’m glad we’re in touch: for a few years after we broke up we couldn’t talk without fighting, and so we stopped talking, and I liked that a lot less. He was my first serious boyfriend and we dated for almost two years, and I’m interested in the occasional updates on his life/wife/kids, and I like feeling like the kind of person who can be friendly with an old boyfriend. Plus, occasional contact with him reminds me how extremely not sorry I am that we broke up (he’s a little dumb).
If you’re in touch with an ex, and they make a negative remark about their marriage, how do you react? My rule of thumb OVERALL for emails to an ex (even with no remarks about the spouse) is to make my entire email completely readable by the ex’s spouse AND by Paul: like, I do a final proof-read thinking to myself “Would it be okay if his wife read this? if Paul read this?” and making sure the answer is a definite, obvious YES. (I do make exceptions to this overall policy at times, but I want them to be exceptions I’ve thought about, not oblivious ones.) So if my old high school boyfriend makes some small complaint about his wife, I’m inclined to answer something like “Oh, I am DEFINITELY with your wife on this one,” or something jokey.
But if an ex says, as part of a newsy update, that he thinks his 20-year marriage is probably ending, my usual light/jokey approach doesn’t work. Also, just for further information, this is an ex who called me the day I was getting married to ask me to not get married, saying he’d send me a plane ticket to come be with him, which is the sort of thing that can seem romantic in movies but truly stupid in real life. [Kerry had a good question for clarification: this was my FIRST wedding, the one where I was 20 years old. It was a long, long, long time ago.] This is also an ex who long ago used to periodically float stuff about how wouldn’t it be crazy if we ended up together when we were old and widowed. He hasn’t done much of that kind of talk recently, and it didn’t seem like he was serious even at the time (he’s the kind of guy who loves silly romantic pop ballads and Oprah specials about high school sweethearts reuniting), but I still felt it was better to err on the side of fully squashing it each time by saying very direct things such as “Even if we were both available, I wouldn’t want us to date; it is enormously clear to me that we were not a good match.” And when he would say things like “Imagine if we’d gotten married!,” I would say “We would have had two kids and then a very messy divorce, and we’d still be fighting now.” Anyway. Just so you see why I want to be extra careful about stuff like this with him, even though it might not still be an issue.
Possible reactions I’ve considered:
1. No reaction. Just answer everything else, leave that part alone. He said it very casually, and it was hard to tell how serious it was, and he didn’t give much to go on.
2. Saying I’m sorry to hear that, paired with a hope that things will work out. (I go with “things will work out” because it sounds like a hope for the marriage to continue, but still applies if the marriage ends: I do hope things work out, one way or another. I didn’t like when I was getting a divorce and some people acted as if it were a giant tragedy and that the only positive outcome was staying married.) Maybe add on something nice about the wife and their relationship? Like, “I’m sorry to hear about you and Steph, and I hope things work out. From what you’ve told me, it’s always seemed like you were good together.”
Hm. I like the last sentence of the second option from the “imagining the wife reading the email” point of view, and from the “it’s CLEAR I am not hoping they split up, or in any way encouraging it” point of view—but it seems like saying more than I know; and also, if they’re not good together, who cares if I wrongly thought they were? Still, if I imagine being the wife reading that response, I like the way it makes it seem as if he’s been telling me good stories about her over the years. And I really HAVE thought they sounded good together: even his occasional complaints about her made it sound to me as if she was well able to deal with his nonsense in a way that could only be good for him. But maybe it’s better to stick with sorry/hope, to avoid seeming like I’m pressuring him to stay in a bad marriage. Or maybe this is all kind of complicated and it’s better to go with nothing.