I SO APPRECIATED your help with the Books Worth Buying post! So many great comments! Would you like to see the list I made from those comments? Let’s just assume yes!
You may look at it and think, “Hey, wait, not a single one of my suggestions is on this list!” I would say by far the most common reason for a suggestion to not end up on the list is that it was a book I had already read. Of course there were other possible reasons: I had reassured anyone who might share my anxiety about recommending a book someone might BUY, saying that I would look up each book to see if it LOOKED like something I’d like; and I followed through on that, and sometimes I read the description and thought it was something I would want to get from the library later on, but not buy. And sometimes someone suggested books by an author I already know I dislike. And sometimes someone suggested a book by an author, and I’d already added another book by that author to the list from someone else’s suggestion, and I wanted to start with just ONE. And sometimes it was that I thought something along the lines of “I have already added quite a few mystery series to this list, considering I don’t generally read mystery series, so let’s just stop it there for now and come back to this later if it turns out I LOVE mystery series and need more.” And sometimes it was because the book was by a man, and I don’t know about you but I am just SO WEARY of male opinions and male perspective and male points-of-view right now; I did add SOME books by male authors to the list, but those books had to meet a higher standard to be added.
But for the MOST part, if you feel you made good suggestions and yet not a single one is on this list, the most likely explanation is that your suggestions were TOO on the mark and were books I’d already read and liked! It was kind of pleasing, actually, to see how many commenters were apparently picking up EXACTLY what I was putting down, especially considering the patchiness/incompleteness of my listed preferences.
Also! Readers of exceptional (and perhaps worrisome) alertness may notice there are some books on this list that NO ONE MENTIONED! That is because I had already made a start on a books-to-buy list, before asking, but I am putting the WHOLE list here.
Also-also! I have linked rather willy-nilly to hardcovers/paperbacks, based on my own preferences/priorities for the particular book, what the prices were the day I looked, etc. Irritatingly, I notice that sometimes if I link to, say, the hardcover, it will no longer even SHOW the paperback option. I don’t know what to do about that. I am working on it, but some of these links are from before I noticed that was happening. So do double-check: if it looks like there’s only a hardcover, try entering the name of the book in the search field again and see if you get more options.
Final note: with only a few exceptions, this list is in the order of “As I added them,” not in any sort of order of priority/preference. And if you see a typo, I hope you’ll let me know: my eyes were pretty much crossing trying to proof-read all these titles/authors. Okay, that’s the last thing, now I will do the list:
The Revisionaries, by A.R. Moxon (Target link) (Amazon link)
Good Talk, by Mira Jacob (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Sleepwalker’s Guide to Dancing, by Mira Jacob (Amazon link)
Solutions and Other Problems, by Allie Brosh (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Annotated Emma, by Jane Austen and David Shapard (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Annotated Northanger Abbey, by Jane Austen and David Shapard (Amazon link)
The Annotated Mansfield Park, by Jane Austen and David Shapard (Amazon link)
The Emotional Load, by Emma (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Women’s War, by Jenna Glass (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Daughters of Erietown, by Connie Schultz (Target link) (Amazon link)
Anxious People, by Fredrik Backman (Target link) (Amazon link)
Magic Lessons, by Alice Hoffman (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Seas, by Samantha Hunt (Target link) (Amazon link)
Last Things, by Jenny Offill (Target link) (Amazon link)
Redhead by the Side of the Road, by Anne Tyler (Target link) (Amazon link)
Upright Women Wanted, by Sarah Gailey (Target link) (Amazon link)
Just One Damned Thing After Another, by Jodi Taylor (Target link) (Amazon link)
Mexican Gothic, by Silvia Moreno-Garcia (Amazon link)
A Gentleman in Moscow, by Amor Towles (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Dearly Beloved, by Cara Wall (Target link) (Amazon link)
If You Want To Make God Laugh, by Bianca Marais (Target link) (Amazon link)
A Thinking Woman’s Guide to Real Magic, by Emily Croy Barker (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Ten Thousand Doors of January, by Alix E. Harrow (Target link) (Amazon link)
Introducing the Honourable Phryne Fisher, by Kerry Greenwood (Target link) (Amazon link)
An Assembly Such as This, by Pamela Aidan (Amazon link)
Eligible, by Curtis Sittenfeld (Target link) (Amazon link)
Mrs. Everything, by Jennifer Weiner (Amazon link) (Target link)
One Summer, by Roisin Meaney (Amazon link)
The Family Fang, by Kevin Wilson (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Tender Bar, by J. R. Moehringer (Target link) (Amazon link)
Shades of Milk and Honey, by Mary Robinette Kowal (Target link) (Amazon link)
A House Among the Trees, by Julia Glass (Target link) (Amazon link)
Domestic Pleasures, by Beth Gutcheon (Amazon link)
The Spellman Files: Document One, by Lisa Lutz (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Humans, by Matt Haig (Target link) (Amazon link)
A Tale for the Time Being, by Ruth Ozeki (Target link) (Amazon link)
Watching the English, by Kate Fox (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Glass Hotel, by Emily St. John Mandel (Target link) (Amazon link)
Convenience Store Woman, by Sayaka Murata (Target link) (Amazon link)
Where the Past Begins, by Amy Tan (Target link) (Amazon link)
Lab Girl, by Hope Jahren (Target link) (Amazon link)
Erotic Stories for Punjabi Widows, by Balli Kaur Jaswal (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Library Book, by Susan Orlean (Target link) (Amazon link)
The World to Come, by Dara Horn (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Violinist’s Thumb, by Sam Kean (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Starless Sea, by Erin Morgenstern (Target link) (Amazon link)
Home Cooking: A Writer in the Kitchen, by Laurie Colwin (Target link) (Amazon link)
Midnight Riot, by Ben Aaronovitch (Target link) (Amazon link)
The Beekeeper’s Apprentice, by Laurie King (Target link) (Amazon link)
How a Woman Becomes a Lake, by Marjorie Celona (I am not putting links here because the book is very expensive, even used, everywhere I look; it just came out this year, and is apparently an import, and I am in no rush, and I don’t even know if I’m likely to like it, so I will wait for it to get cheaper)
The Secret Lives of Color, by Kassia St. Clair (Target link) (Amazon link)
The House in the Cerulean Sea, by T.J. Klune (Target link) (Amazon link)
High Risk, by Chavi Eve Karkowsky (Target link) (Amazon link)