Baby Girl or Boy Brown, Sibling to Allison

Suzanne writes:

I just discovered your blog. Can you help us come up with a name for baby #2 (if it’s a girl)? We have a daughter named Allison. And if we have a boy he will be named Peter. But if we have another girl she may go nameless because we just can’t come up with something. Here is our list of “rules”.

  1. Must be two syllables or more. A one syllable first name would just sound silly with our one syllable last name.
  2. Cannot be a color (e.g. Amber, Violet, Ivory)
  3. Should not begin with B. I am open to this but hubby is not.
  4. Prefer not begin with A since we already have an Allison. This is still somewhat flexible. We just don’t want to end up with a housefull of “A” names.
  5. Prefer something that has a built in nickname option (For example Allison –> Allie or Lillian –> Lilly or Katherine –> Kate, Katie, etc)
  6. Needs to “mesh” with Allison. In general the style should be the same (i.e. nothing off-the-wall like Rainbow or Sunshine).
  7. Cannot ever be confused for a boy’s name (e.g. Taylor, Samantha (Sam), Patricia (Pat), Carson). I understand this is a growing trend, we just don’t like it.
  8. Should be relatively esy to spell and pronounce. It’s okay if there are some alternate speliings (Allison, Alison, Allyson) but we want a name that 95% of the time, reasonable adults would be able to spell with no trouble.

Some names we have considered are:

Heidi
Amanda
Megan
Whitney
Carolyn
Caroline

Names that are out (due to family or ex association are):

Jennifer
Katherine/Catherine
Donna
Karen
Kristin
Laura
Lauren
Julie
Angela

I’d love to get your readers help. Thanks so much!!

I like your idea about avoiding using the same first initial. This is especially wise early on: the Duggars did not at first intend to use J names for every child, but they thought, “Well, our first three are all J and won’t the fourth feel left out?” And then when they were expecting a fifth, they couldn’t let THAT one be the only one without a J. And look where that has got them.

It looks to me like you’ve already got a good list. My favorites are Heidi, Megan, and Caroline. I’ll add a few more choices:

Jenna
Holly
Lindsay
Laurel
Melanie

I think all five of those go well with Allison—although most of them fail the “clear nickname” guideline. And Lindsay might also fail the “easy spelling” guideline, since it can also be spelled Lindsey. Well, still! I’m adding them! Let’s take it to a vote! Poll is thataway —-> [poll closed; see results below]

That’s a lot of choices, now that I look at it. So why don’t you choose two or three favorites instead of just one, if you want to.

[Poll results:
Heidi: 22 votes, roughly 9%
Amanda: 2 votes, roughly 1%
Megan: 30 votes, roughly 13%
Whitney: 18 votes, roughly 8%
Carolyn: 7 votes, roughly 3%
Caroline: 53 votes, roughly 23%
Jenna: 27 votes, roughly 12%
Holly: 15 votes, roughly 6%
Lindsay: 10 votes, roughly 4%
Laurel: 23 votes, roughly 10%
Melanie: 25 votes, roughly 11%]

Name update 01-19-2010! Suzanne writes:

I’m late to respond but Baby #2 ended up being a BOY. So all of these great suggestions never got any use. Peter David was born July 1.

However, we are now expecing baby #3 and we are having the same issues all over again! I’m not sure my brain can take it!

23 thoughts on “Baby Girl or Boy Brown, Sibling to Allison

  1. Carolyn

    Ooh, great idea nowheymama. My own name is Carolyn, and I was so excited to see it on the list. I don’t know any little people with my name. Let me say that I have always loved it, but I would love it even more if people called me Caro.
    But, I voted for Whitney. I think it sounds great with Allison.

    Reply
  2. Barb @ getupandplay

    Caroline can also be nicknamed Carrie (or a variant spelling). I happen to know a Caroline who went by Ceddy (keddy), which I think is cute.

    I voted for caroline and megan, Meg is a very cute nickname!!

    Reply
  3. Linda

    Caroline! Caroline! Caroline! Love it.

    I will point out, however, that I am saying Car-o-line in my head, not Car-o-lyn. Line as in “I am drawing a line” not Lynn. I think it might be mispronounced sometimes. Also, I’m not a fan of Carol. Would people shorten it to Carol? I like the nickname Cara/Caro.

    Reply
  4. Carolyn

    Carolyn here again. No one has ever shortened my name to Carol, although I’ve often been called Caroline by mistake.

    Reply
  5. WaitingForBaby

    Swistle, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE do not promote the name Laurel too too much until my baby comes along and I get to use it! We’ve been waiting for a girl, it’s our favourite name, and I don’t want her to end up in a whole COHORT of Laurels… please? Just hide the name for a little while longer?
    We have a Laura in the family already, and Lauren is way to popular, so we’ve been treasuring up Laurel as our perfect name.

    Reply
  6. Leslie

    I love Caroline and Megan from the original list, and Laurel from Swistle’s suggestions. Great name choices! Margaret and Madeleine also struck me when I first read the list of criteria. Maddie is cute, and Margaret especially has so many fantastic nickname options: Meg, Maisy, Daisy, Maggie, etc.

    Reply
  7. F8hful Lo

    I picked Whitney, which I really like. However, she asked that it be nickname-friendly, and not many of those names really are. With such a cute name like Allison (Allie), I like the idea of matching it with something equally adorable, like Josie. Or you could name her Margaret and call her Maggie. Or what about Elizabeth – there are a ton of cute nicknames: Lizzie, Izzy, Eliza, Beth….good luck!

    Reply
  8. Extraordinary_hope

    Caroline is a lovely name and that’s what got my vote.

    Other names to consider (though quite a few have more than 2 syllables):

    Cassandra (lots of good nicknames with that one. Cass, Cassie, Sandy), Sophie (though no nicknames that I can think of for that), Olivia (Oli, Liv, Livvy), Gwendolyn (Gewn, Lyn), Trisha (Trish), Kristine (Kris, Krissy,), Meredith (Meri), Charlotte (Lottie), Eleanor (El, Eli, Ela), Jillian (Jill, Jilly), Matilda (Matti), Winifred (Win, Winny, Fred), and finally how about Penelope (Penny)?

    I love baby names, what fun! I’m SO glad that I found this site, thanks Swistle!

    Reply
  9. Frema

    I like the suggestion of Josie as a nickname. The full name could be Josephine. Allison and Josephine or Allie and Josie are both very cute!

    Also, I am pregnant with number two and LOVE the name Penelope if I have a girl. Penny is a great nickname, too.

    Reply
  10. Jill

    I know two sisters Allison and Meredith. You could shorten Meredith to Mary, and I don’t think most people would misspell it. It’s also fairly girly.
    Of the choices in the post, I like Whitney and Carolyn.

    Reply
  11. Steph the WonderWorrier

    I voted for:

    Jenna, Melanie, and Megan.

    Jenna –> Jen

    Melanie –> Mel

    Megan –> Meg

    All three go with Allison, all are classic, well-known names so the spelling shouldn’t be an issue, and all are three names I personally just like. LOL.

    You’ve got lots of great options! Best of luck!

    Reply
  12. Lara Jane

    Natalie popped into my head right away. Nat or Nattie are cute nicknames.

    I also like Bethany, Tabitha, Eleanor, and Isabel.

    You know what, Suzanne? Allison was a great choice for your first little darling because absolutely everything sounds great with her name!

    Reply
  13. Anonymous

    My name is Holly, and I love it because a) I get complimented on it frequently and b) it’s not a super common name. It’s common enough that most people know how to spell it, but out of my graduating class(’02) of 321, there was only one other Holly.

    It doesn’t really have any nickname options (people try to call me Hol, but I don’t like that), but it’s short enough that it doesn’t really need one.

    The only downside is that it gets a little annoying to have people ask if you’re a Christmas baby all the time. (My middle name is the feminine form of Nicholas, so I REALLY get this question a lot.)

    Reply
  14. Steph the WonderWorrier

    I’m back.

    I’m taking out my vote for “Melanie”.

    As “Melanie Brown” is Scary Spice, from The Spice Girls.

    I want to second the nomination of Natalie. I love, love, love that name. And Nat is a CUTE nickname.

    Natalie and Allison. Natalie Brown.

    Perfecto!

    Reply
  15. TeamBrown

    I’m late to respond but Baby #2 ended up being a BOY. So all of these great suggestions never got any use. Peter David was born July 1.

    However, we are now expecing baby #3 and we are having the same issues all over again! I’m not sure my brain can take it!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.