Books: The Story of Beautiful Girl; The Glass Hotel

I brought five books with me to Edward’s appointment on Wednesday, feeling a little silly because what if all we did was go to the appointment and then go home, perhaps with a new prescription? Or what if he WAS admitted to the hospital, but we went home the next day? I took two of the books with me in my backpack and left the other three in the car just in case. I have finished the two from my backpack, and have taken a refreshing little walk out to the parking garage to pick up the other three.

(image from Amazon.com)

The Story of Beautiful Girl, by Rachel Simon (Amazon link) (eBay search link).

It is hard to know whether or not to recommend this book. If someone had described it to me the way I would describe it to you in order to explain why I don’t know if I’d recommend it or not, I would not have read it; but I am glad to have read it, and would not want to have been talked out of it. There are hard parts about the mistreatment and abuse of people with disabilities, in institutions and in communities and by police. It’s hard to read, as it should be, but it feels valuable to learn more about those things, and also to have those points of view represented. And it’s not just bleak/educational: there’s friendship and care and love and the good kinds of secrets. And a major plot point involves an older woman who is suddenly in charge of a baby, and I find those sorts of stories very appealing. I read them the way I used to read books about people getting pregnant: just, if that’s one of the plot points, I will try the book. Which is why I tried this one. But there are times I can handle reading about how bad people can be (knowing that these people continue to exist, and continue to exploit and abuse vulnerable people, even if certain kinds of institutions fall), and there are times I can’t, so even with the balancing factors, this might not be the right book for you right at this moment.

 

(image from Target.com)

The Glass Hotel, by Emily St. John Mandel (Target link) (Amazon link).

You know how with most books, you can tell someone what the book is ABOUT? Not this one. I don’t think I would have selected it based on the flap; I got it because I’d liked Station Eleven by the same author. It’s kind of about a woman named Vincent. (Her name was my main complaint about the book: it was TOO distinctive and TOO confusing, and I kept thinking accusingly that the author did not HAVE to choose that name.) But it’s not just about Vincent; it’s about a lot of Vincent-adjacent people, without being clear as to why it would be about them, or about her. The book just sort of talks about them, and sees things from their points of view, and moves around in time, and some things come together and other things just exist. I don’t know if I’m explaining this well, but I liked the book, and found it kind of intriguing to be reading along without feeling like the story was on a particular PATH.

6 thoughts on “Books: The Story of Beautiful Girl; The Glass Hotel

  1. Suzanne

    I have had The Glass Hotel on my want-to-read list forever… mainly because I also have Station Eleven on my want-to-read list? But I just re-read the description and… it doesn’t sound particularly appealing. I still very much want to read it! Some books you just have to go into with faith, rather than with knowing anything about them, I guess.

    I am VERY GLAD to hear that you were well-prepared for the hospital stay with books. I am hoping you are OVERPREPARED, and that you get out before finishing the next book.

    Reply
  2. Lilly

    I really enjoyed both The Glass Hotel and Station Eleven. When we had both finished reading it, my wife asked me, “who do you think is the main character in Station Eleven?” And we each had very different ideas and answers to that question.

    Reply
  3. D in Texas

    I am so sad you and Edward are still in the hospital; it’s given me a severe case of the frets. I hope his misery is tolerable. May you both be set free very, very soon.

    Re: The Glass Hotel: same, same.

    Sending you thoughts of chocolate, and raising my glass in your honor tonight.

    Reply
  4. Anne

    Thanks for the Glass Hotel info! I am about to read it for book group and I’ve been a little ambivalent. The only reason we chose it was because we all liked Station 11. I am now going to approach it with a better attitude.
    I’ve been thinking of you and Edward and hoping for speedy recovery, and easy cyst resolution. I’m glad you are getting some reading time in, too. The idea of being imprisoned with nothing to do but read always sounds better than the reality…

    Reply
  5. Shawna

    I have read Station Eleven and The Glass Hotel by Emily St. John Mandel, but I also just finished Last Night in Montreal by the same author. My order of preference was Station Eleven, then Last Night in Montreal, and The Glass Hotel last. I didn’t strongly dislike that last one, but I admit the only one I actively liked was Station Eleven, even though I timed my reading poorly – January 2020. When the pandemic was declared my head was full of visions of what happened in that book and it was… very unsettling.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.